Susan Moon on the necessity of alternative
meditation postures
By Susan Moon
I SIT IN a chair. Yes, of course, but I mean I
sit zazen in a chair. This is a recent development, arising no doubt
from a karmic web of causes and conditions, but the primary one is
osteoarthritis in my knees.
Everybody knows that a Zen student truly dedicated to the Way sits
cross-legged on the floor. Buddha was sitting cross-legged when he was
enlightened under the pipal tree 2,600 years ago, and there are millions
of Buddha statues to prove it— sitting cross-legged on altars and
bookshelves all over the world. Several of them are in my house.
The image of Shakyamuni in seated meditation is the essential icon of
Buddhism. And 800 years ago, Eihei Dogen, founder of Soto Zen in Japan,
instructed seekers of the way to “sit either in the full lotus or half
lotus position.” These are ancient yogic asanas, sacred
positions—they come with a warranty. Back in my limber days, I believed
that I was bound to get enlightened if I just sat still long enough in
half lotus on my black zafu. Now I see how unreasonable it would be if
the cross-legged people were the only ones who got to cross over to the
other shore.
These days sitting cross-legged causes me intense pain. Everybody
knows that not turning away from suffering is at the heart of Zen
practice, and this includes not turning away from pain in the knees.
Sesshins (long Zen meditation retreats) are an opportunity to learn to
sit through pain. When there is pain in the knees, if I can see it as
nothing other than pain in the knees, then I will be a happy person with
pain in my knees. So I have been taught, during more than 30 years of
Zen practice.
Some years ago, when I was still a floor sitter, a fellow
practitioner had to move to a chair after knee surgery. (The anecdotal
evidence I’ve heard suggests that a remarkably high proportion of Zen
practitioners require knee surgery.)
::read more here